M. Night Shyamalan can't catch a break, it seems.
His latest release, "Lady in the Water," has been met with nothing but criticism from film reviewers and moviegoers. Most of the criticism is focused on the "silly, made up language" and "childish tale" that he weaves in the film.
Make no mistake, M. Night clearly warns the viewer from the very beginning of the movie that this is a fairy tale...a bedtime story for children, performed by adults. The movie opens with a crudely drawn, animated backstory to this fable. Later, there is even a retelling of the fairytale, from a character's mom, to a childlike, Paul Giamatti.
So, we are given ample opportunity to suspend our sophisticated notions of realty cinema. We are forced to watch the film as children. And, if watched through the eyes of a child, the magic of the story does take hold.
Paul Giamatti plays a troubled, but kind-hearted soul, who takes care of the unwitting "Narf" Queen, Bryce Dallas Howard (hot). Both performances are quality, and totally believable even as nonsensical words flow from their mouths.
All of the characters in the film have a role to play in the fairy tale, and their lives take on new meaning.
I am not embarrassed to say that I enjoyed the tale very much. It did force me to put on my kid lens...but when I did, I was rewarded with a completely unique cinematic experience.
Give it a try!&09;
Lady in the Water
i love this movie.
Lady in the Water
I liked it too.
I just think that people had the wrong expectations for the film. M. Night warns us outright that this is a "bedtime story."
Lady in the Water
PLEASE tell me it was better then The Village !! The ending was a let down.
_________________________________________________________
"DO NOT MEDDLE IN THE AFFAIRS OF DRAGONS FOR YOU ARE CRUNCHY AND GOOD WITH KETCHUP"
Lady in the Water
I was one of the minority who really enjoyed "The Village." I thought M. Night did a terrific job creating that feeling of disorientation (not knowing what the time period really was). I thought the acting was top-notch (Joaquin Phoenix, Bryce Dallas Howard, Adrien Brody, and William Hurt were terrific in the film).
I'd have to go with "The Village" as being a better film than "Lady in the Water." Having said that, and realizing that I am a die-hard M. Night fan, I think you may not like "Lady."
Hope this helps.
Lady in the Water
It was okay. could've been better !!!
Lady in the Water
Another horrible movie..what the hell is a narf?
I fell asleep midway through
Lady in the Water
it was diffrent but good i liked it
Lady in the Water
I thought The Village had a nice twist...I haven't seen Lady in the Water, yet everyone has been bashing it except for you guys and gals. I think I will rent it this weekend.
Lady in the Water
I may be the minority, but I didn't mind the village because I know what it was trying to do. As far as Lady in the Water it seemed more like a fairy tale then a horror, but I still enjoyed it.Still, it could have been better.
Lady in the Water
I guess I'm in the minority as well, since I liked the Village. However, I did not like Signs at all. Thought it was boring. My mental jury is still out on Lady in the Water, but I'll probably give it a chance.
Pages
Add new comment