There are a lot of older horror out there that is plenty scary. How about trading those Leprechaun movies in for some old Vincent Price Poe movies or when I was young there were those joke movies like House and House 2 and a great one called April Fools Day, very funny slasher and has a surprise ending. I miss the horror I grew up with. This would help fight the repetition.
You guys have picked some pretty great genre's in the past. I'm totally in to the Asian horror; the originals are much better than the American remakes. Keep trying, the only problem I have with Fearnet is the repetition.