I gotta say, after all the HORRIBLE reviews I read, I was expecting much worse. So let me just say a few things.....
I think that for the most part, if you walked into this movie expecting something incredible and then was disapointed, you really need to re-evaluate your judgment. You should have expected roughly an hour and a half of re-hashed "the hills have eyes" esque suspense and horrible acting. It's a formula, and it keeps people coming to the movies. Furthermore, I find it interesting that people pay to go to a movie and then NOT enjoy it. No matter how bad it was, get your $10 worth.
Also, yes we get it. The people in the movie are stupid and if that were you, you would have done this or that.... Well, let me put this to you as simple as possible. No stupid decisions, no horror movie. I mean imagine a friday the thirteenth where all the cast was making the best possible decisions... it would be a pretty stupid fucking movie. Ya jason NOT killing people that's what I want to see... I realize that "they could have used more imagination when writing the script" or whatever.... but like I said, it's a formula and it has worked since the beginning.
And you really have to give the movie some credit. It had some really great spooky shots. Awesome location and atmosphere, and the suspense scenes really weren't half bad. I would have liked to see more gore, but hey, they can't ALL be evil dead 2 now can they.
Basically what I want to say is... If you are going to see a movie that is obviously going to be a so-so movie, don't go in with delusions of gradure. I mean, you paid, sit down shut the fuck up and forget about your mortgage, work or whatever for an hour and a half and try to let the movie do it's thing. Otherwise, wait until something more promising like Promethius.